Wednesday, April 14, 2021
Insurance Sidebar :: Amy Stewart Law’s Blog on Insurance Coverage Issues Minimize

Amy Stewart Named Among Nation’s Best Lawyers

Congratulations to Amy Elizabeth Stewart for being selected to the 2015 edition of The Best Lawyers in America based on her successful work for clients in insurance law cases. This is the third consecutive year that Ms. Stewart has been recognized by Best Lawyers, one of the nation’s premier guides to the country’s top lawyers.

Read the rest of entry »

Is Monkey Business Covered?

In a news article yesterday, the Washington Post discussed the thought-provoking question on everyone’s mind:  “If a monkey takes a selfie in the forest, does he own it”?  Take British nature photographer David Slater, to wit, who is currently gridlocked in a legal battle with Wikimedia Commons over the copyrights to a selfie taken by crested black macaque in 2011, while Slater was in Indonesia.  

The now-famous photo, published here with permission, has spurred controversy as to whether the intellectual property rights belong to Slater, the monkey, or the people at large.

The battle began in earnest after the images showed up on Wikipedia, and then on Wikimedia Commons, an internet-based encyclopedia.  Slater maintains that Wikimedia’s use of the photos, which are available to the public for free, have hurt his business.  According to a similar article published by Reuters, Wikimedia claims that the photos are in the public domain, “because as the work of a non-human animal, it has no human author in whom copyright is vested,” and has declined to remove the photos from its website.

Equally as interesting though, is whether all this monkey business is covered by insurance.  Claims for injunctive relief, which would force Wikimedia to remove the photographs, are typically not covered by standard insurance products.  However, David’s claim for damages may be covered as a “personal and advertising injury” liability under Wiki’s general liability policy.  And more likely than not, given that the Wikimedia is behemoth media publisher, David’s claims are covered under a specific media content or media liability policy.     

Either way, we are rooting for David, and not just because Wikimedia’s claim that the photos are the property of the public domain simply because David didn’t push the button of his own camera is inherently unfair.  See for yourself.   The monkey is cute, but David…David takes a pretty good selfie too!
(David J Slater)

Read the rest of entry »

Firm Web Site Minimize
Please visit our web site at
About Minimize
Amy Stewart Law is a boutique law firm that represents policyholders exclusively in insurance coverage litigation and bad faith, with an emphasis in directors & officers liability, cyber insurance, fiduciary liability, professional liability and other specialty liability coverages.

Practice Areas Minimize
  • insurance coverage litigation
  • bad faith litigation
  • policy interpretation & analysis
  • insurance review & planning advice
  • advice | insurance disputes
Amy Stewart PC | Dallas, Texas | Copyright 2020 | All Rights Reserved